Tuesday 6 October 2009

Germinal

New year, same problems. Although a very interesting lecture I found the material very difficult to comprehend in such a fast pace session, which was a problem I had encountered last year.



However I did see a connection between the philosophy and Germinal, which I think isn't particularly subtle. The idea of revolutionary change in Germinal, is represented through a miner's strike which Zola naturally took an interest in because it showed the world had not reached perfection as people were revolting through strikes, its foundation (the workers) were unhappy and were causing society to crumble. Which is what D. Sandy Petrey argues in his article 'The Revolutionary Setting of Germinal' by saying



"Strikes became the primary symbol of socialist revolt. Zola consequently left his study of the commune to La Debacle to incarnate the movement of the proletariat in a strike, a subject whose vast dramatic potential had never before been exploited in a novel".



This I feel connected really well to the Young Hegelians because they preached against Hegel who claimed the world had reached its ultimate perfection, well, surely if people are rebelling against the system that is already in place it cannot be perfect, as a perfect society would please everybody. However this connection may not have been as obvious to others, if not I would be very interested in hearing other impressions. Tell me what you think?

2 comments:

Chris Horrie said...

Very good notes. More could be said about Zola though - his mad idea of scientific novel, his method of realism, his theory of sensationalism in writing, his theories of genetic determinism and pre-destination of human nature... that kind of thing. The metaphor of the strike and the miners/proletariat being planted in the ground like the 'seed' of a new world to grwo from the entombed coal miners... also his brutal depiction of social life... It is surprising to me that such an incredibly violent and hate filled book- which is so full of ideas - does not provoke more of a reaction.

Glenn Hutt said...

Horrie singled out your notes so I thought I would build on them, I did it on my blog...

Have a look if you want :)

http://hutt21.blogspot.com/2009/10/emile-zola-hcj-week-1.html